// Asset Usage Detector - by Suleyman Yasir KULA (yasirkula@gmail.com) using UnityEngine; using UnityEditor; using System.Collections.Generic; using System.Reflection; using Object = UnityEngine.Object; namespace AssetUsageDetectorNamespace.Extras { public enum Phase { Setup, Processing, Complete }; public class AssetUsageDetectorWindow : EditorWindow { private const float PLAY_MODE_REFRESH_INTERVAL = 1f; // Interval to refresh the editor window in play mode private const string PREFS_SEARCH_SCENES = "AUD_SceneSearch"; private const string PREFS_SEARCH_ASSETS = "AUD_AssetsSearch"; private const string PREFS_SEARCH_DEPTH_LIMIT = "AUD_Depth"; private const string PREFS_SEARCH_FIELDS = "AUD_Fields"; private const string PREFS_SEARCH_PROPERTIES = "AUD_Properties"; private const string PREFS_PATH_DRAWING_MODE = "AUD_PathDrawing"; private const string PREFS_SHOW_TOOLTIPS = "AUD_Tooltips"; private AssetUsageDetector core = new AssetUsageDetector(); private SearchResult searchResult; // Overall search results private List objectsToSearch = new List() { new ObjectToSearch( null ) }; private Phase currentPhase = Phase.Setup; private bool searchInOpenScenes = true; // Scenes currently open in Hierarchy view private bool searchInScenesInBuild = true; // Scenes in build private bool searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly = true; // Scenes in build (ticked only or not) private bool searchInAllScenes = true; // All scenes (including scenes that are not in build) private bool searchInAssetsFolder = true; // Assets in Project view private List searchInAssetsSubset = new List() { null }; // If not empty, only these assets are searched for references private int searchDepthLimit = 4; // Depth limit for recursively searching variables of objects private bool restoreInitialSceneSetup = true; // Close the additively loaded scenes that were not part of the initial scene setup private string errorMessage = string.Empty; private bool noAssetDatabaseChanges = false; private BindingFlags fieldModifiers, propertyModifiers; private SearchResultDrawParameters searchResultDrawParameters = new SearchResultDrawParameters( PathDrawingMode.ShortRelevantParts, false ); private double nextPlayModeRefreshTime = 0f; private Vector2 scrollPosition = Vector2.zero; // Add "Asset Usage Detector" menu item to the Window menu [MenuItem( "Window/Asset Usage Detector" )] private static void Init() { AssetUsageDetectorWindow window = GetWindow(); window.titleContent = new GUIContent( "Asset Usage Detector" ); window.minSize = new Vector2( 325f, 220f ); window.LoadPrefs(); window.Show(); } // Quickly initiate search for the selected assets [MenuItem( "Assets/Search for References", priority = 1000 )] private static void SearchSelectedAssetReferences() { ShowAndSearch( Selection.objects ); } // Show the menu item only if there is a selection in the Editor [MenuItem( "Assets/Search for References", validate = true )] private static bool SearchSelectedAssetReferencesValidate() { return Selection.objects.Length > 0; } // Quickly show the AssetUsageDetector window and initiate a search public static void ShowAndSearch( IEnumerable searchObjects ) { ShowAndSearch( new AssetUsageDetector.Parameters() { objectsToSearch = searchObjects } ); } // Quickly show the AssetUsageDetector window and initiate a search public static void ShowAndSearch( AssetUsageDetector.Parameters searchParameters ) { if( searchParameters == null ) Debug.LogError( "searchParameters can't be null!" ); else if( searchParameters.objectsToSearch.IsEmpty() ) Debug.LogError( "searchParameters.objectsToSearch can't be empty!" ); else if( !EditorApplication.isPlaying && !Utilities.AreScenesSaved() ) Debug.LogError( "Save open scenes first!" ); else { Init(); AssetUsageDetectorWindow window = GetWindow(); if( window.objectsToSearch == null ) window.objectsToSearch = new List(); else window.objectsToSearch.Clear(); foreach( Object obj in searchParameters.objectsToSearch ) window.objectsToSearch.Add( new ObjectToSearch( obj ) ); window.errorMessage = string.Empty; window.currentPhase = Phase.Processing; window.searchResult = window.core.Run( searchParameters ); window.currentPhase = Phase.Complete; } } private void OnDestroy() { if( core != null ) core.SaveCache(); SavePrefs(); if( searchResult != null && currentPhase == Phase.Complete && !EditorApplication.isPlaying && searchResult.IsSceneSetupDifferentThanCurrentSetup() ) { if( EditorUtility.DisplayDialog( "Scenes", "Restore initial scene setup?", "Yes", "Leave it as is" ) ) searchResult.RestoreInitialSceneSetup(); } } private void SavePrefs() { SceneSearchMode sceneSearchMode = SceneSearchMode.None; if( searchInOpenScenes ) sceneSearchMode |= SceneSearchMode.OpenScenes; if( searchInScenesInBuild ) sceneSearchMode |= searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly ? SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsTickedOnly : SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsAll; if( searchInAllScenes ) sceneSearchMode |= SceneSearchMode.AllScenes; EditorPrefs.SetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_SCENES, (int) sceneSearchMode ); EditorPrefs.SetBool( PREFS_SEARCH_ASSETS, searchInAssetsFolder ); EditorPrefs.SetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_DEPTH_LIMIT, searchDepthLimit ); EditorPrefs.SetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_FIELDS, (int) fieldModifiers ); EditorPrefs.SetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_PROPERTIES, (int) propertyModifiers ); EditorPrefs.SetInt( PREFS_PATH_DRAWING_MODE, (int) searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode ); EditorPrefs.SetBool( PREFS_SHOW_TOOLTIPS, searchResultDrawParameters.showTooltips ); } private void LoadPrefs() { SceneSearchMode sceneSearchMode = (SceneSearchMode) EditorPrefs.GetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_SCENES, (int) ( SceneSearchMode.OpenScenes | SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsTickedOnly | SceneSearchMode.AllScenes ) ); searchInOpenScenes = ( sceneSearchMode & SceneSearchMode.OpenScenes ) == SceneSearchMode.OpenScenes; searchInScenesInBuild = ( sceneSearchMode & SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsAll ) == SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsAll || ( sceneSearchMode & SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsTickedOnly ) == SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsTickedOnly; searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly = ( sceneSearchMode & SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsAll ) != SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsAll; searchInAllScenes = ( sceneSearchMode & SceneSearchMode.AllScenes ) == SceneSearchMode.AllScenes; searchInAssetsFolder = EditorPrefs.GetBool( PREFS_SEARCH_ASSETS, true ); searchDepthLimit = EditorPrefs.GetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_DEPTH_LIMIT, 4 ); // Fetch public, protected and private non-static fields and properties from objects by default fieldModifiers = (BindingFlags) EditorPrefs.GetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_FIELDS, (int) ( BindingFlags.Public | BindingFlags.NonPublic ) ); propertyModifiers = (BindingFlags) EditorPrefs.GetInt( PREFS_SEARCH_PROPERTIES, (int) ( BindingFlags.Public | BindingFlags.NonPublic ) ); try { searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode = (PathDrawingMode) EditorPrefs.GetInt( PREFS_PATH_DRAWING_MODE, (int) PathDrawingMode.ShortRelevantParts ); } catch { searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode = PathDrawingMode.ShortRelevantParts; } searchResultDrawParameters.showTooltips = EditorPrefs.GetBool( PREFS_SHOW_TOOLTIPS, false ); } private void Update() { // Refresh the window at a regular interval in play mode to update the tooltip if( EditorApplication.isPlaying && currentPhase == Phase.Complete && searchResultDrawParameters.showTooltips && EditorApplication.timeSinceStartup >= nextPlayModeRefreshTime ) { nextPlayModeRefreshTime = EditorApplication.timeSinceStartup + PLAY_MODE_REFRESH_INTERVAL; ; Repaint(); } } private void OnGUI() { // Make the window scrollable scrollPosition = EditorGUILayout.BeginScrollView( scrollPosition, Utilities.GL_EXPAND_WIDTH, Utilities.GL_EXPAND_HEIGHT ); GUILayout.BeginVertical(); GUILayout.Space( 10 ); // Show the error message, if it is not empty if( errorMessage.Length > 0 ) EditorGUILayout.HelpBox( errorMessage, MessageType.Error ); GUILayout.Space( 10 ); if( currentPhase == Phase.Processing ) { // If we are stuck at this phase, then we have encountered an exception GUILayout.Label( ". . . Something went wrong, check console . . ." ); restoreInitialSceneSetup = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Restore initial scene setup (Recommended)", restoreInitialSceneSetup ); if( GUILayout.Button( "RETURN", Utilities.GL_HEIGHT_30 ) ) ReturnToSetupPhase( restoreInitialSceneSetup ); } else if( currentPhase == Phase.Setup ) { if( ExposeSearchedObjects() ) errorMessage = string.Empty; GUILayout.Space( 10 ); GUILayout.Box( "SEARCH IN", Utilities.BoxGUIStyle, Utilities.GL_EXPAND_WIDTH ); searchInAssetsFolder = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Project view (Assets folder)", searchInAssetsFolder ); if( searchInAssetsFolder ) { GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); GUILayout.BeginVertical(); ExposeAssetsToSearch(); GUILayout.EndVertical(); GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); } GUILayout.Space( 10 ); if( EditorApplication.isPlaying ) { searchInAllScenes = false; searchInScenesInBuild = false; } else if( searchInAllScenes ) GUI.enabled = false; searchInOpenScenes = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Currently open (loaded) scene(s)", searchInOpenScenes ); if( EditorApplication.isPlaying ) GUI.enabled = false; searchInScenesInBuild = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Scenes in Build Settings", searchInScenesInBuild ); if( searchInScenesInBuild ) { GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Ticked only", searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_100 ); searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly = !EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "All", !searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_100 ); GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); } if( !EditorApplication.isPlaying ) GUI.enabled = true; searchInAllScenes = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "All scenes in the project", searchInAllScenes ); GUI.enabled = true; GUILayout.Space( 10 ); GUILayout.Box( "SEARCH SETTINGS", Utilities.BoxGUIStyle, Utilities.GL_EXPAND_WIDTH ); GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Label( new GUIContent( "> Search depth: " + searchDepthLimit, "Depth limit for recursively searching variables of objects" ), Utilities.GL_WIDTH_250 ); searchDepthLimit = (int) GUILayout.HorizontalSlider( searchDepthLimit, 0, 4 ); GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); GUILayout.Label( "> Search variables:" ); GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Public", ( fieldModifiers & BindingFlags.Public ) == BindingFlags.Public, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_100 ) ) fieldModifiers |= BindingFlags.Public; else fieldModifiers &= ~BindingFlags.Public; if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Non-public", ( fieldModifiers & BindingFlags.NonPublic ) == BindingFlags.NonPublic, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_100 ) ) fieldModifiers |= BindingFlags.NonPublic; else fieldModifiers &= ~BindingFlags.NonPublic; GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); GUILayout.Label( "> Search properties (can be slow):" ); GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Public", ( propertyModifiers & BindingFlags.Public ) == BindingFlags.Public, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_100 ) ) propertyModifiers |= BindingFlags.Public; else propertyModifiers &= ~BindingFlags.Public; if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Non-public", ( propertyModifiers & BindingFlags.NonPublic ) == BindingFlags.NonPublic, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_100 ) ) propertyModifiers |= BindingFlags.NonPublic; else propertyModifiers &= ~BindingFlags.NonPublic; GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 10 ); // Don't let the user press the GO button without any valid search location if( !searchInAllScenes && !searchInOpenScenes && !searchInScenesInBuild && !searchInAssetsFolder ) GUI.enabled = false; noAssetDatabaseChanges = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "I haven't modified any assets/scenes since the last search (faster search)", noAssetDatabaseChanges ); if( GUILayout.Button( "GO!", Utilities.GL_HEIGHT_30 ) ) { if( objectsToSearch.IsEmpty() ) errorMessage = "ADD AN ASSET TO THE LIST FIRST!"; else if( !EditorApplication.isPlaying && !Utilities.AreScenesSaved() ) { // Don't start the search if at least one scene is currently dirty (not saved) errorMessage = "SAVE OPEN SCENES FIRST!"; } else { errorMessage = string.Empty; currentPhase = Phase.Processing; SceneSearchMode sceneSearchMode = SceneSearchMode.None; if( searchInAllScenes ) sceneSearchMode = SceneSearchMode.AllScenes; else { if( searchInOpenScenes ) sceneSearchMode = SceneSearchMode.OpenScenes; if( searchInScenesInBuild ) { if( searchInScenesInBuildTickedOnly ) sceneSearchMode |= SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsTickedOnly; else sceneSearchMode |= SceneSearchMode.ScenesInBuildSettingsAll; } } // Start searching searchResult = core.Run( new AssetUsageDetector.Parameters() { objectsToSearch = !objectsToSearch.IsEmpty() ? new ObjectToSearchEnumerator( objectsToSearch ) : null, searchInScenes = sceneSearchMode, searchInAssetsFolder = searchInAssetsFolder, searchInAssetsSubset = !searchInAssetsSubset.IsEmpty() ? searchInAssetsSubset : null, fieldModifiers = fieldModifiers, propertyModifiers = propertyModifiers, searchDepthLimit = searchDepthLimit, noAssetDatabaseChanges = noAssetDatabaseChanges } ); currentPhase = Phase.Complete; } } } else if( currentPhase == Phase.Complete ) { // Draw the results of the search GUI.enabled = false; ExposeSearchedObjects(); GUILayout.Space( 10 ); GUI.enabled = true; restoreInitialSceneSetup = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Restore initial scene setup after search is reset (Recommended)", restoreInitialSceneSetup ); if( GUILayout.Button( "Reset Search", Utilities.GL_HEIGHT_30 ) ) ReturnToSetupPhase( restoreInitialSceneSetup ); if( searchResult == null ) { EditorGUILayout.HelpBox( "ERROR: searchResult is null", MessageType.Error ); return; } else if( !searchResult.SearchCompletedSuccessfully ) EditorGUILayout.HelpBox( "ERROR: search was interrupted, check the logs for more info", MessageType.Error ); Color c = GUI.color; GUI.color = Color.green; GUILayout.Box( "Don't forget to save scene(s) if you made any changes!", Utilities.BoxGUIStyle, Utilities.GL_EXPAND_WIDTH ); GUI.color = c; GUILayout.Space( 10 ); if( searchResult.NumberOfGroups == 0 ) GUILayout.Box( "No results found...", Utilities.BoxGUIStyle, Utilities.GL_EXPAND_WIDTH ); else { GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); // Select all the references after filtering them (select only the GameObject's) if( GUILayout.Button( "Select All\n(GameObject-wise)", Utilities.GL_HEIGHT_35 ) ) { GameObject[] objects = searchResult.SelectAllAsGameObjects(); if( objects != null && objects.Length > 0 ) Selection.objects = objects; } // Select all the references without filtering them if( GUILayout.Button( "Select All\n(Object-wise)", Utilities.GL_HEIGHT_35 ) ) { Object[] objects = searchResult.SelectAllAsObjects(); if( objects != null && objects.Length > 0 ) Selection.objects = objects; } GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 10 ); searchResultDrawParameters.showTooltips = EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Show tooltips", searchResultDrawParameters.showTooltips ); GUILayout.Space( 10 ); GUILayout.Label( "Path drawing mode:" ); GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Full: Draw the complete paths to the references (can be slow with too many references)", searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode == PathDrawingMode.Full ) ) searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode = PathDrawingMode.Full; GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Shorter: Draw only the most relevant unique parts of the complete paths that start with a UnityEngine.Object", searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode == PathDrawingMode.ShortRelevantParts ) ) searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode = PathDrawingMode.ShortRelevantParts; GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Space( 35 ); if( EditorGUILayout.ToggleLeft( "Shortest: Draw only the last two nodes of complete paths that are unique", searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode == PathDrawingMode.Shortest ) ) searchResultDrawParameters.pathDrawingMode = PathDrawingMode.Shortest; GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); searchResult.DrawOnGUI( searchResultDrawParameters ); } } GUILayout.Space( 10 ); GUILayout.EndVertical(); EditorGUILayout.EndScrollView(); } // Exposes objectsToSearch as an array field on GUI private bool ExposeSearchedObjects() { bool hasChanged = false; bool guiEnabled = GUI.enabled; Event ev = Event.current; GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Label( "Asset(s):" ); if( guiEnabled ) { // Handle drag & drop references to array // Credit: https://answers.unity.com/answers/657877/view.html if( ( ev.type == EventType.DragPerform || ev.type == EventType.DragUpdated ) && GUILayoutUtility.GetLastRect().Contains( ev.mousePosition ) ) { DragAndDrop.visualMode = DragAndDropVisualMode.Copy; if( ev.type == EventType.DragPerform ) { DragAndDrop.AcceptDrag(); Object[] draggedObjects = DragAndDrop.objectReferences; if( draggedObjects.Length > 0 ) { for( int i = 0; i < draggedObjects.Length; i++ ) { if( draggedObjects[i] != null && !draggedObjects[i].Equals( null ) ) { hasChanged = true; objectsToSearch.Add( new ObjectToSearch( draggedObjects[i] ) ); } } } } ev.Use(); } if( GUILayout.Button( "+", Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ) ) objectsToSearch.Insert( 0, new ObjectToSearch( null ) ); } GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); for( int i = 0; i < objectsToSearch.Count; i++ ) { ObjectToSearch objToSearch = objectsToSearch[i]; GUI.changed = false; GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); Object prevAssetToSearch = objToSearch.obj; objToSearch.obj = EditorGUILayout.ObjectField( "", objToSearch.obj, typeof( Object ), true ); if( GUI.changed && prevAssetToSearch != objToSearch.obj ) { hasChanged = true; objToSearch.RefreshSubAssets(); } if( guiEnabled ) { if( GUILayout.Button( "+", Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ) ) objectsToSearch.Insert( i + 1, new ObjectToSearch( null ) ); if( GUILayout.Button( "-", Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ) ) { if( objToSearch != null && !objToSearch.Equals( null ) ) hasChanged = true; objectsToSearch.RemoveAt( i-- ); } } GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); List subAssetsToSearch = objToSearch.subAssets; if( subAssetsToSearch.Count > 0 ) { GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); // 0-> all toggles off, 1-> mixed, 2-> all toggles on bool toggleAllSubAssets = subAssetsToSearch[0].shouldSearch; bool mixedToggle = false; for( int j = 1; j < subAssetsToSearch.Count; j++ ) { if( subAssetsToSearch[j].shouldSearch != toggleAllSubAssets ) { mixedToggle = true; break; } } if( mixedToggle ) EditorGUI.showMixedValue = true; GUI.changed = false; toggleAllSubAssets = EditorGUILayout.Toggle( toggleAllSubAssets, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ); if( GUI.changed ) { for( int j = 0; j < subAssetsToSearch.Count; j++ ) subAssetsToSearch[j].shouldSearch = toggleAllSubAssets; } EditorGUI.showMixedValue = false; objToSearch.showSubAssetsFoldout = EditorGUILayout.Foldout( objToSearch.showSubAssetsFoldout, "Include sub-assets in search:", true ); GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); if( objToSearch.showSubAssetsFoldout ) { for( int j = 0; j < subAssetsToSearch.Count; j++ ) { GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); subAssetsToSearch[j].shouldSearch = EditorGUILayout.Toggle( subAssetsToSearch[j].shouldSearch, Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ); GUI.enabled = false; EditorGUILayout.ObjectField( string.Empty, subAssetsToSearch[j].subAsset, typeof( Object ), true ); GUI.enabled = guiEnabled; GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); } } } } return hasChanged; } // Exposes searchInAssetsSubset as an array field on GUI private void ExposeAssetsToSearch() { Event ev = Event.current; GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); GUILayout.Label( "Search in following asset(s) only:" ); // Handle drag & drop references to array // Credit: https://answers.unity.com/answers/657877/view.html if( ( ev.type == EventType.DragPerform || ev.type == EventType.DragUpdated ) && GUILayoutUtility.GetLastRect().Contains( ev.mousePosition ) ) { DragAndDrop.visualMode = DragAndDropVisualMode.Copy; if( ev.type == EventType.DragPerform ) { DragAndDrop.AcceptDrag(); Object[] draggedObjects = DragAndDrop.objectReferences; if( draggedObjects.Length > 0 ) { for( int i = 0; i < draggedObjects.Length; i++ ) { if( draggedObjects[i] != null && !draggedObjects[i].Equals( null ) ) searchInAssetsSubset.Add( draggedObjects[i] ); } } } ev.Use(); } if( GUILayout.Button( "+", Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ) ) searchInAssetsSubset.Insert( 0, null ); GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); for( int i = 0; i < searchInAssetsSubset.Count; i++ ) { GUILayout.BeginHorizontal(); searchInAssetsSubset[i] = EditorGUILayout.ObjectField( "", searchInAssetsSubset[i], typeof( Object ), false ); if( GUILayout.Button( "+", Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ) ) searchInAssetsSubset.Insert( i + 1, null ); if( GUILayout.Button( "-", Utilities.GL_WIDTH_25 ) ) searchInAssetsSubset.RemoveAt( i-- ); GUILayout.EndHorizontal(); } } private void ReturnToSetupPhase( bool restoreInitialSceneSetup ) { if( searchResult != null && restoreInitialSceneSetup && !EditorApplication.isPlaying && !searchResult.RestoreInitialSceneSetup() ) return; searchResult = null; errorMessage = string.Empty; currentPhase = Phase.Setup; } } }